06Oct2009
“Phone A Friend” Lifeline Removed from “Millionaire” Thumbnail

“Phone A Friend” Lifeline Removed from “Millionaire”

Edit: I’m sure I made it clear in the post, but I wanted to specify that this is really not the end of the world or the downfall of the show like many are claiming it is. I just think it’s a bit of a cheap way of solving a problem, whatever that problem may be.

Yeah, I defend the show a lot through the changes it’s made when others hated them. I’m not sure I can defend this much. I can’t give you the date yet, but the ever-popular Who Wants to be a Millionaire lifeline Phone A Friend is being removed from the show. Nothing will replace it, and Ask the Expert will be available at the start of the show. So, again, from the beginning your three lifelines are Double Dip, Ask the Expert, and Ask the Audience (the only thing really surviving from the original show ten years ago). And it kinda sucks. I wish I could defend like I’ve defended other changes, but I can’t. There’s really nothing positive from getting rid of it. I can understand why they are doing it from a production standpoint, but from my fan standpoint it’s a bit lame.

I’m just going to take two wild guesses at what this could be about so we can think from a production standpoint before we move into critical mode. The first thing (and the more probable) is that they have to do some extra production work with Phone A Friend which, you guessed it, costs money. They have to get all these people, make the graphics, organize it all, keep them on the phones, and then they have to edit down the dead time on set between when the lifeline is activated and when you actually see it on TV. The second is about Googling. At least half the Phone A Friends Google the answer which guarantees a right answer. So that’s a lot more money than they’d give away normally, thus saving money. So either way it boils down to money. I wish I had the right answer but I’d have to Phone A Friend for that and apparently it’s not allowed anymore.

It’s the only thing I can think of, though. It’s not like it wasn’t that popular, like 50:50. It is basically a cultural catch phrase. If they are going to keep toying with it in an effort to save money, whether that be production costs or prize budget or both, I’d really just like to see the show play around with the Australian Millionaire: Hot Seat format and bring it here. It only has one winner each show and that win averages around $20K usually, with $50K+ some other days. This is not, “That’s it, I’m done watching!” change. This is just more, “OK this is a bit dumb,” change.

I feel dumb for complaining about something as small as a lifeline, but it makes it so much harder to win money now. Ask the Audience stops being helpful at around the $12,500 or $15,000 question. People don’t like to do gambling with Double Dip much so that’s left on the table later. Ask the Expert is completely useless half the time when we get celebrities and Entertainment Weekly editors on the panel. I’d rather see the show start from scratch with the Hot Seat show than continue the endless stream of $15,000 or $25,000 winners with basically no one having a remote shot at a million dollars except for tournaments like the Tournament of 10.

Author
Alex Davis

About the Author

has written 2834 articles on BuzzerBlog.

Alex Davis is an award winning writer and producer based out of Pittsburgh, PA, who works out of New York, Los Angeles, and London. Alex is the head writer and editor for BuzzerBlog and is the president and head of development of 5Hole Productions, specializing in unscripted formats for television and internet play.

Visit this author's website   ·   View more posts by

Share This.
  • Subscribe to our feed
  • Share this post on Delicious
  • StumbleUpon this post
  • Share this post on Digg
  • Tweet about this post
  • Share this post on Mixx
  • Share this post on Technorati
  • Share this post on Facebook
  • Share this post on NewsVine
  • Share this post on Reddit
  • Share this post on Google
  • Share this post on LinkedIn

Discussion

74 responses to "“Phone A Friend” Lifeline Removed from “Millionaire”"

  • Roy says:

    2. The lifelines. Specifically, the misuse of them. Of course, the Ask the Audience becomes useless after the first 10 questions, but a lot of contestants either use it on a question people don't know or they don't trust a high number. Double Dip tends to be used just to confirm an answer they're not sure about. Even if their instinct is wrong, that sometimes is their only thought and they're stuck taking a wild guess almost. They also compound it with another lifeline sometimes which really annoys me. Ask the Expert is used on a lot of questions that don't match their expertise, so they get mostly vague answers. A lot of them don't present certain answers, which only makes the contestant uncertain.

  • Roy says:

    PAF became a lot less helpful over the years despite the emergence of Google. Half of the contestants spend 10 seconds reading the question and then the rest repeating the answers, while the other half expects the PAF to look up the answer (to the person who said they're sequestered, much of the connecting phase is edited out for TV). Even in the latter group, you get a lot of "I don't know"s and other unhelpful responses. Removing PAF isn't a JTS moment if it's not the worst of issues.

    I do think they could sequester the PAF somewhere or let contestants use banked time if they're stuck, but the removal of PAF alone isn't going to kill the show.

  • Roy says:

    PAF became a lot less helpful over the years despite the emergence of Google. Half of the contestants spend 10 seconds reading the question and then the rest repeating the answers, while the other half expects the PAF to look up the answer (to the person who said they're sequestered, much of the connecting phase is edited out for TV). Even in the latter group, you get a lot of "I don't know"s and other unhelpful responses. Removing PAF isn't a JTS moment if it's not the worst of issues.

    I do think they could sequester the PAF somewhere or let contestants use banked time if they're stuck, but the removal of PAF alone isn't going to kill the show.

  • Linda says:

    The reasoning Meredith gave for removing phone a friend is weak. She said the answer should be what is in your mind. Well, asking the audience is not in the contestant's mind, as well as asking the expert is not in their mind.

  • Linda says:

    The reasoning Meredith gave for removing phone a friend is weak. She said the answer should be what is in your mind. Well, asking the audience is not in the contestant's mind, as well as asking the expert is not in their mind.

  • AKG says:

    I thought for a long time they should remove phone a friend and let people have 30 seconds to google the answer. It's not as easy as it looks to google something in 30 seconds, and most people's phone a friends couldn't get them any answers at all anyway.

  • AKG says:

    I thought for a long time they should remove phone a friend and let people have 30 seconds to google the answer. It's not as easy as it looks to google something in 30 seconds, and most people's phone a friends couldn't get them any answers at all anyway.

  • bgluckma says:

    That's it. I can't take it any more. I've removed Millionaire from my TiVo season pass. Since the show has removed the Phone A Friend lifeline, I'm getting tired of watching a parade of contestants walking with between $5K and $15K. What bothers me is not only that the $1M now becomes even more unreachable, but I never get to ponder the answers to the most challenging questions because the contestants rarely get beyond $25K. I'll miss Meredith, but since the lifeline change the show has become much less entertaining and challenging for me.

  • bgluckma says:

    That's it. I can't take it any more. I've removed Millionaire from my TiVo season pass. Since the show has removed the Phone A Friend lifeline, I'm getting tired of watching a parade of contestants walking with between $5K and $15K. What bothers me is not only that the $1M now becomes even more unreachable, but I never get to ponder the answers to the most challenging questions because the contestants rarely get beyond $25K. I'll miss Meredith, but since the lifeline change the show has become much less entertaining and challenging for me.

  • Christian says:

    They had an episode where the guy didn't even read the question in the 30-second time limit; he just enunciated the keywords and told him the responses, asked which one fit. Incidentally, he got the question right.

  • Christian says:

    They had an episode where the guy didn't even read the question in the 30-second time limit; he just enunciated the keywords and told him the responses, asked which one fit. Incidentally, he got the question right.

  • @joshandallo says:

    "Their" is relative. "Their" means the contestant's mind, the audience's mind, the expert's mind, and the PaF's mind. Simply put, anyone who the question is relayed to must use their mind to figure out the correct response and to not use the aid of some sort of technology to help them answer the question.

    I completely understand why PaF was removed, but I think it should have stayed, but with much more stricter rules. Since the contestant's friends and or family usually come along, why not replace them and have the contestant's phone a friends come along instead? They would be secluded backstage, and when the time comes to use the lifeline, they could use video conferencing (perhaps Skype could sponsor this as well?) to the friend backstage and without the aid of Google, answer the question.

  • OCdeck says:

    Well, it’s just a game, in every game there’s always consequences and changes. There’s always a winner and a looser. In every game you have to be professional and only trust in your ability and skills. Just believe in yourself and a bit of efforts.

Leave a Comment