I’m on vacation so hopefully these automatic posts work. It’s always a gamble. Here’s a quick little place you can throw your opinions about Million Dollar Password which debuts tonight at 8:00PM ET on CBS.
Network: CBS
Airings: Sundays at 8:00PM ET
Host(s): Regis Philbin
Vote for how many stars you think the show deserves to the right, and then leave a comment!
Million Dollar Password is a revamp of the classic word game format. In the new version’s elimination round, two contestants play four rounds of 30 second guessing games, with five passwords to get per round. The players switch celebrities at round three. Most points at the end of round four plays for $1,000,000 in the money round. Here, the contestant and celebrity with who he or she played the best in the main game must get five words out of a certain amount in order to move up the money chain. After winning $25,000; the player can’t leave with less than that. After six successful rounds, the player wins $1,000,000. Not completing a goal in any round loses money won up to that point and the player leaves with the last milestone.
I get to be the person who few agree with as usual: I’m just not a big fan. I can stand the game play if necessary but even then I have issues. We get more gameplay out of the first few minutes than we do in the money round, the round they are actually trying to promote more. It’s the issue I had with Friend or Foe?. They answered more questions in that last 60 seconds than they do in the rest of the game. On Password it’s basically the reverse of that: more game play in the first five minutes of a game than the actual portion they promote. And I still don’t think the money round format works. This comes from me, again, just not thinking Password works for a million dollar format, at least in the format we have here which is essentially Pyramid without the giant pyramid.
My main issue with the show is the presentation. The set’s nice and fine, but the rest is just not working. The constant applause after each word is distracting and throws off the vibe of what they are wanting to make: a tense word game. And that’s not working either. I’m feeling no tension or connection, I’m just watching. The music is bland background noise like I’d expect from Chain Reaction. I feel like I’m watching Sony’s Pyramid, to be quite honest. The never ending whooshes and sound effects get old very quickly as well. Again, just like Pyramid. Regis almost seems out of his game here. He gets no chance to connect with contestants which is what he was good at. Donny Osmond from Pyramid would have been just as good and probably cheaper. But they seemed to advertise the show on the fact that it had Regis which was a troubling sign to me from the start. No, this is far from a bastardization of a format like Fremantle did with Temptation. And who knows, maybe this will lead to a syndicated series eventually which is where this show works. However, it’s not working as a dramatic format, the presentation is just too much, and it needs more even pacing.
Rating: 




61 Responses
Allen Ludden's Ghost
1June 1st, 2008 at 7:13 pm
Someone sedate the audience during the :30 rounds, please. The applause is a deterrent to the contestants. Also, Doogie Howser is terrible as a Password player. Let’s see how the bonus round works. . . .
Narro87
2June 1st, 2008 at 7:24 pm
So far, they gave this show the polish it deserved–the music and stage are spot-on. The elimination round certainly ends quickly, but at least they give the interaction between the contestant and celebrity during what apparently is the main game. I think that the hurdle of risking all money earned will soon keep this from being interesting–if the words are getting harder, why not just let the contestants play until they fail out normally and give them the money from the level they stopped at? Who honestly is going to play for the million, knowing they have to get every one of the most difficult words correct? I hope I’m proven wrong later in the show.
John S.
3June 1st, 2008 at 7:25 pm
Giving away $1,000,000 or more is such a cliche now. But yes, not great password players. I’m betting that this show would feature a $1,000,000 win.
How come that this game uses the same gameplay format as “Power of 10?”
Brandon
4June 1st, 2008 at 7:27 pm
So far, it’s pretty decent, but there’s too much audience sweetening going on, esp. when someone gets a word right.
The no returning champions rule sucks, but it’s apparently par for the course nowadays…
Marc Power
5June 1st, 2008 at 7:34 pm
Regis seems right at home and that doesn’t surprise me, I like the pace of the main game and the bonus round, the set is incredible, SFX & theme music are typical for this day and age,
I don’t like the $25,000 safety, it seems to come too soon. if it were at $50,000 it would be better. It seems unnecessary to me to have a $1M prize, a $100,000 prize would have sufficed. and yeah Neil is pretty bad but the show hasn’t been on for 19 years, after a few shows people will pick up tricks and strategies and that will improve gameplay. also, i think it should be contestant’s choice on their celb. partner for the bonus round instead of basing it on who they did better with, especially since she didn’t get to finish her round with Rachel Ray, and I don’t think a 3-clue limit is totally necessary here either, maybe 5 clues or no limit, but I like the 90 second limit it keeps the game moving.
Allen Ludden's Ghost
6June 1st, 2008 at 7:43 pm
Perhaps I was a bit harsh on NPH up there. He tightened up a bit in the big money round. Mr. Power speaks the truth when he says that the $25k safety comes to soon. Another one at 100k might help the contestants along a bit, and guarantee us another round when the money gets high. And a “here is your first word” from Regis might be nice here and there, coming from an old Pyramid fan. I always thought those were dramatic words.
Narro87
7June 1st, 2008 at 7:55 pm
Four words: The preview is brilliant. That might be the most amazing way to entice people to go higher. I’m actually glad they thought of that!
Matt B
8June 1st, 2008 at 7:58 pm
I like the preview, although the producers “shafted” the hell out of him with fiasco. His clues were brilliant up until corner. NPH did all he could. Good show.
Brandon
9June 1st, 2008 at 8:01 pm
After seeing the whole thing, I’ve come to the conclusion that it’s not your grandfather’s Password.
And I still liked it. Fremantle made changes that actually bring the show into the 21st century. I give it a B. Stop with the audience sweetening, and I’ll like it even more.
Jeff H
10June 1st, 2008 at 8:18 pm
First thoughts right after seeing the episode:
1) Agree on the audience, needs to stay quiet during the word rounds themselves.
2) I thought Regis was ok, but he’s not the center of this show. They probably would have done just as well with somebody less famous and have the two celebrity players be the focus.
3) I thought the rounds themselves were good. I think the contestant should get to choose who they are partnered with on the money ladder though.
4, and biggest point) There is no way I would go for the million with this format, even with the preview. Absolutely not. The bar needed to clear is too insanely high. I doubt many will even go for the 250K, so my solution (to at least insure longer second segments) is either having two guarantees at 25 and 100K or move the single guarantee up to 50K.
I’m in agreement with you Alex. This is not a format for a million dollar show. But it’s not a bad show overall. Personal verdict: lower the top prize and move it to syndication.
davec
11June 1st, 2008 at 8:20 pm
I have to say I was pleasantly surprised as well.
The elimination round is almost a bit more like “Pyramid” meets “Password”, but, I think it retains enough of being Password to work.
The “Million Dollar Game” I think worked pretty well, considering they were trying to get it in the “Millionaire” step-style of game that basically any prime time game show seems to have to do at this point.
I agree that ‘fiasco’ was an incredibly hard word, but, I think that was the point. The five words he was previewed were pretty doable, which is why they do the preview I think, although if you got caught up on one (like he did with “corner”. My 3 clues, although would I have thought of them on the show?…. billiards, pocket, siiiide…), then you are stuck with a hard word with no pop-culture or common thing you can link to it, like fiasco. Obviously he got caught being the first contestant, so, he wasn’t aware of that. Now people will know, you’d BETTER get it with the five they show you, or else you are stuck with a near impossible word.
My guess is that they’ll also “preview” the 5 words for the Million. Another thing they might do (I have no idea, just seems like would help get people to go for it) is actually give SIX possible words, and if the contestant decides to go for it, they can pick which word gets thrown out before they play the “5 out of 5″. Almost more of a psychological thing (”Hey, I can pick which words I do!”), but, it would help get more people to go for it.
insaneben
12June 1st, 2008 at 8:20 pm
It was somewhat better than I thought it’d be.
Neil Patrick Harris (for anyone who didn’t know what NPH stood for before this post) certainly came around during the main game. Although I do agree that $25,000 is a little too early to grant a safety net (then again, I have a feeling they will be a few players who will stumble at the 25 or even 10 grand mark). One thing that should’ve happened at the end of each failed main game is that Regis should chime in with a few alternative clues the contestant/celeb should’ve used (like Bert Convy used to do on Super Password).
Also, that female contestant in the second elimination round really screwed up (and Rachel Ray did better than I thought she would have).
I agree that the numerous applause is unnecessary (like the contestants concentrate, please). A couple other gripes I have are the fact that you have to wait for your partner to take a guess before you can move on to the next clue (this is all find and good in the main game, but in the elimination round, it’s annoying and unnecessary) and the numerous camera jump cuts/edits (I thought an ADD-beleaguered child was operating the editing booth).
All gripes aside, this show certainly has promise (though I’d still like to see Super Password make a return, this time in syndication).
Brad D.
13June 1st, 2008 at 8:23 pm
I thought that the show was pretty good. Going to break it down here:
Host- Regis is as good as expected. (9/10)
Gameplay- The beginning elimination game is basically the bonus round of the original password in the 60’s but with two contestants and two celebs to see what contestant can get the most words. It works well. The big money round after is good too. I was skeptical of the concept but it’s executed fairly well. The only gripe I have is with the 3 clue limit. There has been many times in password bonus rounds in which they used a lot of time on one word and still came back to win. Instead maybe for each round they should cut the time down maybe 5 seconds each level. This will allow the player to use their time better instead of wasting it trying to think of a good clue while still making it harder. I would also up the safety level to $50,000 instead of $25,000. (8.5/10)
Set- The set is pretty nice. It’s typical but it’s still nice. I like how the floor elevates during the big money round. (8/10)
Music- Again typical. Doesn’t sound anything different from most game shows these days. It would of been better if they would have remixed an old password theme in some way. (7/10)
Overall-8 out of 10
The show is good. Some old time password fans may not like it but I personally feel that the format used in previous passwords would bore most these days who aren’t familiar with the previous passwords. They had to speed up the gameplay to keep the attention of today’s typical television viewer. The celebs weren’t the best in playing but I’m pretty sure that they will get better when they came back (that is if they do). I was really rooting for the guy who’s stuff got robbed during the big money round. For fiasco, I would of gave the clue “lupe” (which is also the name of a famous hip-hop artist). But Anyways, I can see this show having a good run as long as CBS doesn’t change it’s time (like they did with Power of 10).
Brad D.
14June 1st, 2008 at 8:26 pm
Oh and also, the preview of the words during the big money round is a great way to make the player consider moving on. Great idea.
davec
15June 1st, 2008 at 8:31 pm
Just a question with the “fiasco” word…
Is emphasizing part of the word illegal? My thought is, give a clue like “CriSCO” or “NabiSCO”. And then two words to try to make them think of fiasco, and hopefully they got the hint that it ends in “SCO”.
Brad D.
16June 1st, 2008 at 8:37 pm
^No it isn’t illegal. They do it with some words during the show if they are opposites (player can tell in the tone of voice if the word is an opposite).
I personally think that “lupe” would of been the best clue since lupe fiasco is a popular hip-hop artist but I doubt that Neil would have gotten it.
Adam
17June 1st, 2008 at 8:46 pm
I really like Million Dollar Password. Regis is a great host. NPH really showed that he was a good Password player. I’m glad Fremantle didn’t screw up Bob Stewart’s creation. I’ll be tuning in every Sunday for Million Dollar Password. I bet Allen, Tom and Burt are pleased right now. Can’t wait to see Betty!
Julia
18June 1st, 2008 at 8:55 pm
The Password is CRAP! What was this? I was interested, but it did not deserve the name Password. The front game, what 90% of the original game was, is reduced to Pyramid with one word clues. The pacing is so quick that if you blink, you forget the other contestant and celebrity existed. The million dollar round is just horrible. Does every new game show have to have a money tree and play for a million? Plus, what was with all the music in the background? Watch shows on GSN, and you’ll hear something very interesting…silence. Does everything have to be so fast paced with music in between? do producers actually think that 5 seconds of quiet will get people to go, “OMG! This is so boring. I’m switching to MTV?” I’m sorry, but the more I watch GSN and see how game shows have gone to crap in the past decade the more I love the classics. There is actually some tension without music. The continuous background music gave me a headache.
Sorry about my ramble, but I really did not like this. It seemed polished, but for THIS day and age. Password is not supposed to be like this. Password was such a tense and dramatic show. Freemantle has tarnished yet another franchise.
There are two good things about this, though. Regis and the time slot. Regis is always good, but in this format, he doesn’t really get a chance to be himself. 8PM on Sundays assures this show being a hit.
Intelligenfan777
19June 1st, 2008 at 9:13 pm
I can’t really say anything that hasn’t been said already. Good show, I think the format has been updated nicely.
Also, yes, they indeed had the foresight to add a “preview” for the upper levels! Contestants will be enticed to go on, even though it still will be hard to find people who might try for the million. But, I feel the point is, make the Million hard, but certainly not impossible to win. They have that here.
I hope we see some bigger winners next week, and in the weeks ahead. One week features Rosie O’ Donnell, and from what we’ve heard, she was an “impressive” player. And of course, Ms. Password herself, Betty White is also featured! Can’t wait for that.
jaymich1128
20June 1st, 2008 at 9:16 pm
I think the new version is great. True, the new changes make the game go quicker…but, I got used to it. The $25,000 safety is probably to early…but a lot of shows (e.g. Lyrics and 5th grader) have an early safety zone (and no other), so I thought this was par for the course.
I remember the older versions (and watch them on GSN). I’m glad they didn’t change how a clue is ruled illegal.
The only thing I would change is this: if the receiver doesn’t know it right away, let the giver know right away by saying “clue” quicker. By “thinking about it”, you’re wasting time. I had the same problem on “The Weakest Link”…only this time, you’re screwing with one contestant’s money…not a shared jackpot…but that could change (I hope).
I’ve never been crazy about Regis…but that’s just a personal decision. But, this time, he’s mainly in the background. I liked how he let the players play the game…and not trying to take over.
As for the “fiasco” fiasco (pun intended), it was $250,000…he had already won the $100,000. So, there had to be a catch of some sort. As for going for the Million, I doubt there would be a choice. I think it would just be the 5 words…and that’s it. To me, it would resemble the original “lightning round”…5 words in a certain time limit (in that case, one minute). Except, in the lightning round, they could pass…it was $50 per word…but they couldn’t return to a passed word. I think being forced to play all 5 words is a good rule for $1,000,000. After all, in most shows (if not all), there isn’t any lee-way (sp?) when they go for $1,000,000…in fact, in 5th Grader, the cheats disappear for the Million Dollar Question. So, having to deal with every single word seems fair to me.
As a final thought, Password was known to aid in educating students for the entire time it was on. Maybe students will use this tool again.
AEI
21June 1st, 2008 at 9:19 pm
I think “fiasco” rather appropriately sums up the “million dollar” money round. There are some good things–but there are definitely some kinks in the format that need to be worked out. Regis, the NPH, and Rachel Ray were just fine–Harris in particular was trying to have some fun with the format, which a lot of celebrities on these shows don’t do. And Regis was his usual self, inasmuch as the format permitted.
I find myself not minding the structure of the rounds in the money ladder. It’s essentially an extension of the “Ca$hword” format from “Super Password.” Five right in 90 seconds with no reference point–and the audience distractions and clue limits–seems reasonable.
The main issue right now, like everybody else, is with the structure of the money ladder itself. After watching this first episode, they should rename the show from “Million Dollar Password” to either “$100,000 Password” or “Idiots-Flushing-Large-Amounts-of-Money-Down-the-Drain Password.” I think the problem is that they picked contestants with decent, but not solid, playing ability. I would have taken a look at “canteen” and “corner,” figured one of them would be a no-go, realize that I have no clue what the next word might be, and take my $100K and run.
I also agree with the posters above who have complaints with the main game. They could use a shortened version of the original Password format, with clues alternating between teams, and worth one less point each time it gets passed back and forth. (Say, 5 points and counting down.) First team to 20 or 25 points wins a round; first team to win two rounds advances to the bonus round. Alternatively, they could make the main game more exciting by making it a cash game, X dollars per word (500-1000, perhaps).
Damion
22June 1st, 2008 at 9:20 pm
OK!! Julia, take a chill pill!!! Fremantle did not entirely tarnish this one. I liked the show very well, and it did go better than most people would’ve thinked. I really got into that last round where the guy ALMOST won $250,000. My three clues for “CORNER” would’ve been “STREET”,”POINTY”, and “SHAPE”. The money tree is a bit distorted with the next level after $250,000 being $1,000,000 but overall, this was a good show. Fun to watch.
Allen Ludden's Corpse
23June 1st, 2008 at 9:21 pm
What game show will Regis Philbin’s corpse host? He’s 76, not early to decide. This version of PW sucks donkey ass.
Myke25
24June 1st, 2008 at 9:48 pm
Well, as a big Password fan and a big Pyramid fan, I kinda like how they married them. It is paced like Pyramid and plays like Password.
They said that this would take the best parts of all of the previous versions of Password. It doesn’t. It’s the original lightning round on crack. But I kinda liked it.
Regis was great. The celebrities were OK…not great, but most of the great Password and Pyramid celebs grew into it over time. If this show takes off, the stars will be OK.
And I loved how the players introduced the civilians, just like on the original.
Here’s what I didn’t like:
Password was a serious game played for fun. The tone of MDP is all deadly dramatic and tense. Hopefully they’ll lighten up in time. And would someone please compose some decent game show music for a change?!
The Games are the same: the elimination game is pretty much exactly the same as the bonus round. I’d like to see them add the “Password Puzzles” from P+ to the elimination game…still do five in 30 sec., but have the passwords lead to the identity of a person, place or thing. The more Passwords you get, the more clues you have to guess the puzzle. Guess the puzzle correctly for two bonus points.
Too many “bonus rounds”: six rounds is way too many for a bonus game. Since this show is mighty Pyramid-flavored already, might as well go all the way. Keep the money tree, but give the player the choice of leaving with their winnings, or risking it by facing another contestant to get to the next rung.
I liked the set, But I didn’t like that the players were standing. NPH had his hands in his pockets the entire show. Looked awkward.
Is 90 seconds too long? They only get 3 clues per password. Tonight, when they lost, it wasn’t because they ran out of time. They ran out of clues. One minute might suffice.
But hey, I wasn’t expecting it to be perfect. I didn’t really expect to like it much, but I did like it…a lot. If the ratings were decent, I hope the folks at Sony were taking some notes for the inevitable Pyramid revival.
George
25June 1st, 2008 at 9:56 pm
I was not expecting good things from this version, I came away pleasently suprised. I am a password fan from the ABC days (later the + and Super versions) I agree with the what everyone is saying the audience clapping etc. Ill be watching, finally a show that Fremantle didn’t completely destroy.
Sam
26June 1st, 2008 at 10:13 pm
I found it quite entertaining myself. I also thought the preview at the $250,000 level is a great idea to dangle a carrot for the players to go on. And then, they spring “fiasco” on you. Genius.
I realized that the money round is like a bunch of Super Password’s Ca$hwords. The format worked quite well, I think. Rachel Ray, however, needs to stick to cooking. :P
Looking forward to the next episode!
Julia
27June 1st, 2008 at 10:14 pm
This show is not Password. It’s “One-Word-Clue Pyramid” without the categories. While both shows are Bob Stewart creations, that doesn’t give them the right to mesh them together and call them the name that Freemantle owns. If Sony put this together it would have the same format and be called Million Dollar Pyramid, and the Winner’s circle would be a little different, but not much, from the MD Password format. Very sad. Does anyone have any new ideas these days? Plus, the show is dramatic enough. You do not need to add fake drama to a former format that had enough to begin with.
I might watch next week, if I’m home. If it sucks just as bad as this week, I won’t give it another shot.
Bring back the Super Password/Password + format, please. Watching them today made me realize just how great they were, and watching tonight’s MD Pyramid bastardization made me realize how much crap Freemantle produces nowadays. If the show hasn’t been around since before Freemantle (i.e. TPiR and Family Feud), any remake by them will suck horribly.
Shon
28June 1st, 2008 at 10:23 pm
Wow! So far this is pretty bad.
For starters password in general is suppose to be a laid back game. Even Super Password as intense as it got in times was laid back. Which is why with the time limit in the elimination round just kills it. It feels too much like Pyramid. Also like everybody else has said the celebs aren’t great password players which is vital.
The bonus round even feels like Pyramid especially when Regis says “Do you want to give or recieve?”. In general it’s unforgiving especially since there is a three word limit and a timelimit. What was wrong with alphabetics?
The only things I liked was the set and Regis. The music sucks.
In general this is too much like Pyramid and doesn’t resemble the previous passwords. More importantly it doesn’t have the charm that those passwords had either which is probably why it will get canceled in a couple of weeks..
Erskine Thompson
29June 1st, 2008 at 10:36 pm
I’m a lifetime game show fan, with a special place in my heart for word-association games, particularly Password. As such, I became really nervous about “Million Dollar Password” after reading Alex’s preview of it, and seeing the trailers.
After having watched the show, I have to say, I really enjoyed it. I thought it really clicked, and was a very good modern interpretation. In trying to respond to some previous comments:
The host: Regis is, like him or not, associated with the idea of giving away $1,000,000. Thanks to “Millionaire,” just having him on makes the show mean something to the general public, even if it doesn’t have that effect on hardcore game show people.
The qualifying game: I won’t call it the main game, because what you’re all calling the bonus game is actually the main. The qualifier is just a means to an end, like on “Power of 10.” That said, it moves quickly, but not frenetically, and I thought it was quite exciting. It will be even moreso once some players show up that are better at the game.
The celebrities: Gotta promote the CBS properties, I guess. Harris was fine; Rachael Ray was actually outclassed, I think. The only problem here is that one celebrity winds up being featured the entire show, while the other becomes an afterthought if they do poorly in the qualifier.
The main game: I’m in the minority, but I think the money ladder really works. I like the safety at $25,000 because it is fairly easy to accomplish, but is a big fall from the higher levels. Also, the jumps from 100k to 250k and from 250k to 1 million are good, because you’re allowed to preview the words. If you’re playing well, you don’t mind risking 75k for another 150k, and you might even get a sense that risking 225k for 750k is a good idea, if you’re very confident in your partner. It’s enough of a payoff to make the risk worth it. The only change is that if you lost on the million-dollar game, I’d give an extra $5,000 per word right, as a bonus for trying, added to the guaranteed $25,000. That way, they’ve got SOMETHING for the attempt.
Overall: I really enjoyed it. The pacing was much faster than any other iteration of “Password,” but I don’t think the average viewer today is cerebral enough for the methodical pace we’re used to. However, this might just be the bridge to get “smart” games back in vogue, and might set the stage for “Pyramid” to return, done right this time.
lisa
30June 1st, 2008 at 10:57 pm
Its not bad, but its just not the same game. I miss the puzzles of P+ and Superpassword, it really made you put everything together and think. It was also really the only way pop culture references today, and it would have been interesting to have compared todays references with those of shows past.
I also agree with the previous poster that no one looks like they are having fun anymore. I miss the host/celebrity/contestant/banter, which Regis would have been great at.
Personally, I would have just liked to have seen SP but just make the alphabetics round with higher stakes. Maybe if this show does well that is what they will do in syndication?
Can’t wait to see Betty, though!
Tyrone Allen
31June 1st, 2008 at 11:28 pm
I’d prefer the prelim round to be a tad more casual and closer to the original Password front end game… like a first to fifty points setup. I don’t want it to be speed round after speed round. I think they should clock the clues individually instead of the whole, or give more words and less levels on the ladder. Just something different that a whole bunch of speed rounds.
I still liked it, though. Worth tuning in to again, methinks.
Tim
32June 1st, 2008 at 11:29 pm
Everyone keeps talking about Alphabetics… I don’t know that the ADD viewer would like that. I think the money ladder works, too. The one thing that I would have liked to have seen was the puzzles. I was a little upset when I didn’t see that.
Overall though, I really enjoyed the game and was having fun playing along… thinking of words as clues and really rooting for the players!
I enjoyed it and can’t wait for next week… and for Betty White sometime soon!
Chris
33June 1st, 2008 at 11:35 pm
Honestly, I thought the show was FANTASTIC.
The gameplay was fast, but slow enough to let you tink about clues that you would give and get involved in the drama, and the celebrities were really fun.
Everyone keeps complaining about how it’s not like Password Plus or Super Password, but, honestly, I never really enjoyed the gameplay of those two very much. The core of the game has always been trying to get people to guess the words and finding the “definitive” clue to a certain word. The puzzles were okay, but they always felt like an unnecessary add on. And the new Bonus Round is certainly more dramatic than Alphabetics ever was.
I’d suggest a couple of changes, that others gave mentioned: raise the safety to $50,000, and let the contestant choose which celebrity they take to the Bonus Round.
Other than those few things, this show is really fun (and hopefully) a big summer hit.
Eric
34June 2nd, 2008 at 8:07 am
I can’t believe I’m saying this but Freemantle managed to mess with a classic and make it pretty good. No this isn’t your Grandfather’s password, or even your father’s Password plus, or (for those of you who are my age.) your Super Password. I have to admit at the 100k level I was screaming at the TV when the guy went for it. I agree though that he kinda got shafted with the “mystery” word. I also have to agree that the player should be able to choose who they want to go for the $1,000,000 with. Either that or complete the 2nd half even if the game is over, so that the contestant in theory would have an equal shot of having either celebrity.
George
35June 2nd, 2008 at 9:16 am
I think the reason for the speed round is that they want each show to be self contained, i mean God Forbid a show should stradle! I am in advertising and i pulled some preliminary Nielsen numbers for the show and it looks like CBS has a hit. I pulled local markets the top 13 markets and in most cities MDP was either #1 (all but 1 or 2) in Households and demo. So will see what happens next week. And yes i can’t wait for Betty White (btw, that show will air on a Thurs not sunday…..tony awards are on the 15th BW episode airs the 12th)
ScottNotSteve
36June 2nd, 2008 at 9:45 am
First, it is important to keep in mind that Pyramid was a derivative of Password, so some commonality is not surprising.
1. The front game is basically lightning rounds from the original Password, except for 30 seconds each — does it feel like the front game of Pyramid? Absolutely, but it’s still lightning rounds. The fast pace is really engaing here.
2. The celebs switching with the contestants was a nice touch just as in the original Password (though it was after each game that the switch occurred).
3. The end game is exciting, but perhaps drags too long. Perhaps bag the first level altogether, or use Alphabetrics-style first-letter hints and reduce the time limit a bit. The three-clue limit is actually good here because it forces thoughtful gameplay and makes each clue count. A $100,000 safety would be better, to allow contestants to get a “free” chance at the $250K. The previews answered my question of why anyone would go for the $250K, but don’t screw the contestant, let them see ALL the words before they decide. Not perfect, but it was a decent enough end game to bring me back. AND LET THE CONTESTANT CHOOSE WHO THEY PLAY WITH IN THE END GAME!
4. You could see the pain in NPH’s eyes when the contestant lost the big money and shooted down to 25K — you could tell he felt he let the contestant down and was embarrased into silence. It’s almost too much at stake for a celebrity partner to bear, isn’t it? But great drama, as the contestant was clearly destroyed and still gave NPH a half-hearted hug on the way out.
Overall, better than I thought it would be, nice compact 1/2 hour format per game (times two), easily could make the run to syndication with a few tweaks.
Ryan
37June 2nd, 2008 at 10:36 am
I actualyl found the show to be enjoyable, and moved along, no long drawn out drama.
I hate in teh final round that there is a risk free level. By that, I mean once you get to $25,000, you automatically will try for the $50K. I wish they had structured the money tree as is, but made each level a risk. IE, instead of being guaranteed $25K when you reach the level, the contestant would be guaranteed nothing until they hit the $50K level. Once they earn that, then they are guaranteed $25K if they lose.
It worked OK for millionaire, but I just wish it were a tad bit different here.
Ken Strain
38June 2nd, 2008 at 1:15 pm
I thought the show was pretty good, and I’m an “old school” password fan. Regis did pretty good i thought. I agree with the people that said that the applause during the elimination round is too distracting. The bonus round is well laid out. I like the idea of having less words to used the higher you get.(5-10,5-9)etc. Overall, i would give it a B
Elizabeth Fuller
39June 2nd, 2008 at 3:39 pm
Glad other people thought it was too noisy with all the audience clapping. What really drove me crazy, though, was the constant music playing under everything–even the interviews and game play. It was like an annoying mosquito buzzing in your ear when you’re trying to sleep. Enough, already!
JS
40June 2nd, 2008 at 3:53 pm
I liked the show but hated the set, I think it is too much to have $1,000,000 flying on bars around the set. If they added some color beams that could change colors (I.E. Deal or no deal) and made it more like deal and millionaire, but leave the rising platform, I liked that.
JS
41June 2nd, 2008 at 3:54 pm
I liked the show but hated the set, I think it is too much to have $1,000,000 flying on bars around the set. If they added some color beams that could change colors (I.E. Deal or no deal) and make it more like deal and millionaire, but leave the rising platform, I liked that.
Scott Meckley
42June 2nd, 2008 at 3:56 pm
I was surprised and impressed. My disappointment was that the password puzzles weren’t used which is my thing I loved about password. I loved the fact that it wasn’t drugged out long drama. Neil Patrick Harris is a pretty good password player rachel ray not so much. I actually liked the look of the set and maybe I’m alone here. It kind of remind me of a classic look with primetime appeal to it. I really wish the contestants would have been sitting but all in all I will tune in next week to watch Million Dollar Password. Regis did very well on this too. The bonus round was better than I thought it was going to be which was a surprised to me. All in all i will give this show an A Minus
Bryan Hayes
43June 2nd, 2008 at 3:56 pm
My verdict is mixed; Regis did a top-notch quality job, but the front game resembles Pyramid too much and the bonus round is just a tad too complex though exciting. Also, they really do need to sedate the crowd during the gameplay; this show is way too loud. I compare this version to Drew Carey’s hosting of The Price is Right: not quite the best, but definitely not the worst.
Shon
44June 2nd, 2008 at 4:33 pm
I watched it again this morning and it’s not as bad as I first thought it to be. Alot of my original complaints still stand as I said in my earlier post. It’s just not a original concept for a show anymore. What I mean by this is it seems like you can add a money tree to any game show and almost anybody will watch it. I was hoping that Password would still have a lot of it’s original gameplay and show to the game show world that you do not need a money tree to have a hit. It’s like with reality shows. As a matter of fact I can describe every premise in every reality show in the following paragraph:
“In the begging there will be “X” amount of people and each week and at the end of every episode someone will levae (via judge or voting, etc.) At the end of the series (which is usualy some long boring drawn out finale) someone will win the grand prize (Usually a million bucks)”
This was a great concept in the begging and now that every network follows this (Bravo is the most guilty with the following shows Top Chef, Top Model, Top Janitor, etc.) it’s become boring and tedious. Why can’t there be a new concept going back to my original point that is my main complaint with password. It’s like every game show that has been made in the last ten years. What ever happened to being innovative and being an original?
I could go on all day why this version of password is infierior to the others but instaed I’ll go in to my official review.
On the Loogaroo scale here’s how I rate this version of password.
Gameplay: 1 pts./3 pts.
As I stated earlier this game suffers from the cliche money ladder but the front game is not as bad as I originally claim. It does resemble loosely the old lighting round. The main problem is the bonus round. It is just unforgiving. It either should just be the time limit or the word limit. Both of those together is just over the top. The main difference between Pyramid and Password is Password is more of a thinking mans game and Pyramid is fast and frantic. Either way the game could use better pacing.
Host: 3 pts./3 pts.
Regis does a excellent job and has a nice report with the celebrities. He’s is just as good as all the other password hosts IMHO(but no one still holds a torch to Allen).
Presentation: 1 pts./2 pts.
While the set does look stereotypical, it is original. I love the animated walkways. The only thing I hate is when the set raises in the bonus round. It reminds me of the “Winner’s Circle” from Pyramid. The music is awful. It’s not produced well at all and sounds like all the other million dollar game shows that have existed before it. This also goes for the SFX.
Execution: 0 pts./2 pts.
The whole production feels thrown together and it seems like they didn’t go for the celebrities that knew how to play the game (although they got Betty Whit and I can’t wait to see that ^___^ .) Instead they get Doogie Howser who looked like a deer in the headlights the entire game.
Total Score: 5pts./ 10 pts.
Average
Chad
45June 2nd, 2008 at 4:38 pm
I may be in the minority here, but I didn’t think that the bonus round was at all bad. I realize that beside, perhaps, a 26-letter Alphabetics, there’s not really a way you can give away $1,000,000. If you’re going to make Password for a million, you have to revamp the bonus round. The bonus round was executed pretty well, in my opinion.
I, however did NOT
AO
46June 2nd, 2008 at 5:00 pm
This mash-up of Password, Pyramid and the Power of 10 (strange that they’re all “P” shows) actually turned out to be quite engaging.
The only real problem that I saw was the set. The big jumbotrons seemed to remind me of the old Candid Camera, and the bullseye with the $ in the middle was a bit too cheesy for me. Unfortunately, they also brought the “loud” aspects of the Power of 10, which many have griped about already. I thought it was funny when NPH had his fake laugh before the second half contestants. The red, on the other hand, was actually a welcomed change, as opposed to all of the blues seen in the past (I’m not counting “The Chair”), but it could have toned down a bit on the strobe light.
Regis did do well in this debut, but I felt at times he was rushed. Maybe it was the music, yet I almost counted the number of times his voice went up after a sentence. I think he also had to do some voice-over work, which I’m never a fan of.
As for the gameplay, I really don’t mind the Pyramid portion of it, but I wish they brought the puzzle portion back like the past and slowed it down a tad. I enjoyed the money game (except when it seemed like there was a public execution going on in the last :15 of that final bonus round), however there needs to be some tweaking to it. I like the safety at 25k, and I don’t think you’d like to have it much greater than other shows are sporting. The clock is completely useless if you have the three clue limit, and the words on each level need to be the same (and increasing) difficulty. Clever that they would shows the clues before deciding though. I don’t know if I would be in favor of an Alphabetics, since it would probably have to play out like the WonderWall if there’s no returning champion. For once, the money tree will do.
I’d give it a 7/10. This’ll be a great show once it goes to syndication, but I’ll enjoy it on Sunday’s for now. Rachel Ray was awful and should stop being on TV.
KBGUY09
47June 2nd, 2008 at 6:47 pm
I enjoyed the show and had the same peeves at most people did here so I won’t bother to repeat them. However, some people are saying how the show is going to fast. Try to remember 2005 when DOND first came on the airwaves here in America. The show got through roughly 2-2 1/2 contestants a night. It was moving fast. Then they decided to stall. A lot. Talk with the contestant. Talk with the family. Bring a surprise guest. Go to commercial 3 or 4 more times. Same thing with PlayMania.
So although I would like more banter with the contestants and celebrities, be thankful that the show is running too fast rather than too slow. Overall I think this is very good. Super Password is still my favorite, though.
The other things I do not like about the show is the music and the set. Every show does not have to be a tense show. I think using a Super Password-like set, even in primetime, would still work.
Jeff
48June 2nd, 2008 at 9:00 pm
Where is the happy theme song? Where is the whispering announcer “The password is…” Where is Dr. Riesen A. Goodman or his equivalent? I miss Allen Ludden’s gaze into the camera when the clue was offbeat. Where’s my clock ticking? Tick Tock. Do I need hear that music and the audience constantly applauding? I have always been a Regis fan, but this show is too impersonal with the high tech set and eerie “Millionaire” music throughout. The fast pace made me nervous and it wasn’t fun. Made me want to take a “bufferin” (one of the original Password sponsors!) The password is : Disappointed.
Myke25
49June 2nd, 2008 at 9:59 pm
Does anyone know what happens when the elimination game ends in a tie? It’d be cool of they played classic Password for the tie breaker. Both teams play the same word. Best two out of three wins.
Jeff, unfortunately we live in a world where game show announcers just aren’t very necessary anymore. Except for Price and Wheel where you have a lot of merchandise to describe, most game shows just offer cash. Not much for an announcer to do these days.
I do agree about the lousy, predictable theme music…if you can call it that.
An actual clock tick would be more naturally suspenseful than that artificially dramatic underscore. Even Pyramid’s flute-clock sound haunts me years later.
And it would have been retro-cool to have Regis close with “The Password for tonight is __________.”…followed by a quote or proverb sent in by a viewer, just Like Allen.
But even with a few blemishes, the show wasn’t bad. But I was almost expecting Regis to start the bonus round by saying, “Here’s Your First Password. Go!”
ddele7
50June 2nd, 2008 at 11:57 pm
i liked the show! Fremantle didnt screw this one up. If i had to bring such a show as Password into the 21st Century i would do it like this. I was surprised to hear at the end that it was taped in NYC so it makes it the first old Goodson Todman Show to return to NYC.
The million dollar game was beautifully done. I knew that NPH was screwed when “FIASCO” came up. How do ya give a clue for that.
I love the set. And i liked it how the celebs introduced their partners in the front game, a suttle throwback to the original version of Password. I think were all looking forward for Betty White’s apperance on the show. Let the master show us how its done.
DENo1MatchGameFan
51June 3rd, 2008 at 3:54 am
Overall, I give it an “A” for effort, but at the same time, there are a few things that got me po’ed on this version of “Password”…
1. The audience was WAY too loud - now it is one thing when someone wins the money (i.e. $10,000, $25,000, etc.), but after EVERY CORRECT ANSWER? The audience was subdued on the other “Password” formats, but not here!
2. There could have been a neater theme to the show - since Fremantle owns Mark Goodson Productions, and Score Productions is still in business, why didn’t they let them compose the them (especially since the show is on CBS, where Score Productions made the music for “Up To The Minute?”
3. I thought that Neil Patrick Harris did a great job - Rachel Ray on the other hand… “MDP” needs to get celebrities who can stand up to the ‘pressure’ more (like “Mrs. Betty Honey” White will!)
4. I think that the end game should be more like the Alphabetics/Super Password round, as it would take longer to win the money, and I also miss the puzzles as well.
5. I like Regis as host, and he doesn’t have to be as overbearing as he was on “Millionaire” either.
6. The set was too much like “Millionaire” and Donny Osmond’s version of “Pyramid” - too ‘techno’ for my taste - an updated version of the “Super Password” set would have worked just as well, and been more ‘homey’ to boot!
7. In a way, I’m glad there is no announcer, or Fremantle would probably have stuck Rich Fields on it - then it REALLY would have been a LOUD show!
In closing, I liked it, but “Super Password” is still my all-time favorite version of the game - I’ll always LOVE the ‘TESTIMONY’ episode with Patty Duke and Rip Taylor!
DB25
52June 3rd, 2008 at 6:22 am
Eh, not sure how I felt about this one. My first thought was very similar to most posts here - that the beginning round was just Pyramid with one word clues and no categories. The bonus round was just Ca$hword with a money ladder. I think they could have done better than this. Regis really was almost pointless during the show. They could have hosted the show with a robot. Very C- for me…I wasn’t impressed but I wasn’t totally depressed either.
I heard the ratings were good though.
Greg
53June 3rd, 2008 at 10:17 am
At least somebody agrees with me. It’s too bad this show is relying on Regis and $1,000,000.
Chris R.
54June 3rd, 2008 at 1:12 pm
I felt it was good, but it seemed like the six steps to a million makes it too quick of a journey to big money. It works for the Power of 10, but I don’t think it works for Password. It probably was made that way because CBS wouldn’t make a full commitment to the program.
If they did, I would break the format into 3 segments since it looks like Pyramid in Password’s body:
Win one main game to play the 5 of 10 set for $10,000.
Keep that and leave, or risk it for the first “safe haven” of $25,000.
Win that, then you return to try and win a second main game.
Win two main games to play the 5 of 8 set for $50,000.
Keep that and leave, or risk it for the second “safe haven” of $100,000.
Win that, then you return to try and win a third main game.
Win three main games to play the 5 of 6 set for $250,000.
Keep that and leave, or risk it for the $1,000,000.
I wouldn’t add it, but I would okay with showing a preview of the 5 passwords at the million level for that enticement factor.
Sam
55June 3rd, 2008 at 3:08 pm
I seem to recall a couple of choice ditties from a Futurama episode when I read a couple of these posts here: when it comes to television, unexpected things make people feel scared and TV viewers want to see the same thing they’ve seen a thousand times before.
There’s hell to pay when the new Password doesn’t have any puzzles, that’s for sure. :P
CarShark
56June 3rd, 2008 at 4:24 pm
First off, I hate this posting software. It’s not posted what I’ve written three times.
Second, I give Password three stars. I like the gameplay, but I think Chris R’s idea of using the fast and exciting front game to break up the plodding endgame would be better. The set is too dark, too red and too disjointed. The music is easily forgettable and a synthesized cliche. The celebrities were nice, but not the best players, same as the contestants. Regis was a non-entity, which I’m trying to decide if that’s a good thing or not.
davec
57June 4th, 2008 at 9:04 am
Also, I have to point out, since people have been complaining about the “3 clues” not being a part of “Password” history: I haven’t even seen “Cashword” in this whole thread. Obviously people are forgetting about the “Cashword” game on Super Password, where you only got 3 clues for the bonus check.
So, maybe you don’t like it, but, you can’t say they were not taking various “aspects” of different Password elements over the years with that rule in the new game.
Sam
58June 4th, 2008 at 8:45 pm
Excellent point, davec. I realized that just the other day, but I never posted it.
devares
59June 6th, 2008 at 10:23 am
I LOVE this version. It’s “Password” meets “Pyramid” meets “Millionaire”. FINALLY, Fremantle did something right for a change (although I’m still not a fan of the company). I know CBS is probably celebrating the return of Password in prime time.
Greg
60June 6th, 2008 at 11:50 am
They did something right? I’m sorry, but I have to disagree. The “Password meets Pyramid meets Millionaire” is exactly what’s wrong with the show, IMO.
I’d like to see “Super Password” with the 3-part Lightning Round from “Password ‘75″. That would be an exciting show.
jc
61July 25th, 2008 at 10:36 pm
exactly. the audience was too loud. and either the 10k bonus round level needs to be removed or the safety net moved up or both. I liked the pace, actually, its to the point, word association.
wish regis had bit more of a role in it however..
awesome revival though. keeps me screaming at the TV
RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI
Leave a Reply
GSN Schedules
8/4/2008 to 8/10/2008 8/11/2008 to 8/17/2008 8/18/2008 to 8/24/2008 8/25/2008 to 8/31/2008 9/1/2008 to 9/7/2008 9/8/2008 to 9/14/2008MiniBuzz
Buzz In
Biggest Buzz
Categories
Pages
Archives