We’ve finally got some concrete information in on NBC’s new stunt game show Minute to Win It, debuting March 14th at 8:00PM ET. Previously we were just saying that it was a ripoff of the great British show The Cube because it sounded identical, but we had no concrete proof. The presentation is what may have changed everything. We’ve finally got some concrete information courtesy of our friends at HollywoodJunket. Calling Minute to Win It a ripoff of The Cube is being nice to ripoffs. It’s a blatant reproduction of it under a new name that makes me wonder how much of a case ITV, the network airing The Cube, would have in suing for this. Furthermore it goes to prove they learned absolutely nothing from the Our Little Genius fiasco. Let’s go point by point by how this is a blatant copy that Mark Burnett may want to call to and tell them a little story..
1: Minute to Win It just asks you to do various tasks in 60 seconds. Tasks can include stacking things, knocking things over, throwing things into other things. I can’t fault this as a copy since it’s been the goal and target of a ton of shows, but a lot of the challenges are direct copies of The Cube and it’s a bit too convenient that this show was greenlit as a piss-in-the-face move to Fox, to beat them to the punch.
2: Contestants are given “Lives” for games. They have two to use each stunt, in case they fail a game. They can retry. The Cube has nine “Lives” for the full show. Even the name is the same. Could they not try to at least have been a bit more inventive? It’s like if Are You Smarter Than a Fifth Grader? came outright and said the helpers are now called “Lifelines”.
3: The challenges are presented to the contestants by a female British voice instructing the contestant about the game. Two models are there to assist and make sure everything is fine with the game as well. The game is shown as an “electric diagram on the digital screen” on Minute to Win It. On The Cube a male British voice instructs the contestant about the game as an assistant called “The Body” (done in post) shows the game.
4: In terms of “rigging” the game to be more exciting, HollywoodJunket reports that a contestant failed the first stunt. They let her try again and said it was because of “nerves”. She failed again. They restarted the show from the top with the same contestant and another game which she won. Again, this is exactly what happened on Our Little Genius and while it wasn’t the cause of the show going under, it didn’t help. Contestants are also told the games ahead of time to practice at home, but we’re still looking into this. Reports are saying that the games are posted online for anyone to do so there may have been a verbal mix-up on set, but HJ was very specific in saying contestants were told ahead of time which games were going to be played and that they could practice.
But beyond this, it’s just 10 games to win a million bucks. Once a contestant beats five games and wins $50,000, he or she can’t leave with less than that.
I’ll look into it more, but I do have to wonder if ITV would have any legal case against someone here. It’s a direct clone. The only difference really is The Cube has seven games to win, and this has ten. They use the same terminology, a lot of the same games, and some of the same presentation/example styles. We’ll look up which format came first, since this idea, from Friday TV, was apparently produced by NBC into what we see today. I can’t fault the production company at all. This seems like a knee jerk reaction to beat Fox to the punch. But again, it looks to be nothing intentional on the part of the original creators.
I could even get over it if it was just a clone of The Cube, but the constant contestant forgiveness, and then giving contestants the games before the show so they can win, is a mixture of lame, pathetic, and wrong. It’s amazing that we never have any of these problems when companies who know what they are doing, like Embassy Row and Fremantle, are in charge. NBC can do great game shows. They gave us some of the decade’s greatest. Deal or No Deal, 1 VS 100, Weakest Link; the list goes on. I have no idea what happened here, though. I feel like this was rushed into production because of several poor situations and they borrowed what they had to.
I wish it the best because I want to see more primetime shows. The show does have potential and I’ll still be watching at least the first episode, but it’s got a uphill battle to win. The scheduling sucks for it, I haven’t heard a lot of good from audience reports, and now we’ve got all of this.
Edit: Took out a paragraph; we got more information.